Common Probate Disputes & How to Resolve Them

Introduction

Probate can be an emotional and challenging process. While it’s designed to ensure that a person’s wishes are carried out and their debts are settled, it often opens the door to family conflict. Arguments over inheritances, executor duties, and real estate can turn even the closest families into courtroom adversaries.

As a Certified Probate Real Estate Specialist (CPRES), I’ve helped countless families navigate the complexities of probate—especially when disputes arise. This guide covers the most common types of probate disputes, why they happen, and, most importantly, how to resolve them efficiently and fairly.

What Are Probate Disputes?

Probate disputes occur when beneficiaries, heirs, or other interested parties disagree about some aspect of the probate process. They can involve:
✅ Who inherits what
✅ How estate assets are managed
✅ Executor or trustee actions
✅ Real estate decisions
✅ Validity of a will or trust

Disputes can be emotional and complex, often fueled by grief, misunderstandings, and long-standing family tensions.

Why Probate Disputes Happen

Understanding why disputes arise is the first step toward preventing them. Here are the most common triggers:

1️⃣ Ambiguities in the Will

Poorly drafted wills can leave room for interpretation. When language is unclear, family members may disagree about the testator’s intentions.

👉 Example: A will says, “I leave my property to my children,” but doesn’t specify which property or how it should be divided.

2️⃣ Perceived Unfairness

When one beneficiary receives significantly more than others—or is excluded altogether—it can breed resentment.

👉 Example: A second spouse inherits the family home, leaving adult children feeling disinherited.

3️⃣ Executor Misconduct

Executors have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries. Allegations of mismanagement, favoritism, or dishonesty can quickly turn into disputes.

👉 Example: An executor fails to provide regular accountings or makes questionable financial decisions.

4️⃣ Real Estate Disputes

Real property is often the largest asset in an estate—and the one most likely to cause conflict. Beneficiaries may disagree about whether to sell, how to divide proceeds, or who gets to keep the property.

👉 Example: One sibling wants to sell the family home; another wants to keep it as a vacation property.

5️⃣ Undue Influence or Fraud

If beneficiaries suspect that someone manipulated the deceased into changing their will, a dispute is likely to follow.

👉 Example: A new caretaker inherits everything, and long-standing family members are left out.

Common Types of Probate Disputes

Let’s unpack the most frequent disputes families face:

Will Contests

Beneficiaries may challenge the validity of the will on grounds like:
✅ Lack of capacity
✅ Undue influence
✅ Fraud or forgery
✅ Improper execution

Impact: If successful, the court may invalidate the will or revert to an earlier valid version.

Executor Disputes

Beneficiaries may allege that the executor is:
✅ Mismanaging assets
✅ Failing to communicate
✅ Delaying the process
✅ Favoring certain beneficiaries

Impact: The court can remove the executor and appoint someone else.

Asset Distribution Conflicts

Disputes often arise over:
✅ Unequal inheritances
✅ Sentimental items (e.g., jewelry, heirlooms)
✅ Complex assets (e.g., businesses or real estate)

Impact: These disputes can delay probate and deplete estate funds through legal fees.

Real Estate Disagreements

Probate property disputes often involve:
✅ Whether to sell or keep the property
✅ How to value and distribute proceeds
✅ Managing repairs, taxes, and insurance

Impact: Real estate disputes can be especially emotional, as homes often carry significant family memories.

How to Resolve Probate Disputes

Fortunately, most probate disputes can be resolved without going to trial. Here’s how:

1️⃣ Mediation

Mediation is a confidential process where a neutral third party helps the parties negotiate a settlement. It’s cost-effective, private, and often preserves family relationships.

👉 Pro Tip: Courts often order mediation before trial, and many disputes settle at this stage.

2️⃣ Arbitration

In arbitration, a neutral party hears evidence and makes a binding or non-binding decision. It’s faster than litigation but more formal than mediation.

3️⃣ Family Meetings

Sometimes, open communication can prevent disputes from escalating. A facilitated family meeting—often guided by a CPRES or attorney—can clarify misunderstandings and align expectations.

4️⃣ Probate Litigation

When all else fails, the dispute goes to court. Litigation is costly, time-consuming, and public—but sometimes it’s necessary, especially if fraud or serious misconduct is suspected.

Preventing Probate Disputes

An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Here’s how to reduce the risk of family feuds:

✅ Clear, Detailed Estate Planning: Avoid ambiguities that lead to confusion.
✅ Update Documents Regularly: Life changes—your estate plan should too.
✅ Choose the Right Fiduciary: Pick someone honest, organized, and trustworthy.
✅ Communicate with Heirs: Let them know what to expect to reduce surprises.
✅ Use No-Contest Clauses: These discourage frivolous challenges.

Real Estate and Probate Disputes

Real estate is often the most valuable asset—and the biggest source of conflict—in an estate. Here’s why:

🏠 Valuation: Disagreements over a property’s market value can derail the probate process.
🏚️ Condition and Maintenance: Deferred maintenance can decrease value and cause tension.
💸 Buyouts: When one beneficiary wants to keep the property, they may need to buy out the others—a process that can get complicated without a proper valuation.

As a CPRES, I help families:
✅ Obtain neutral appraisals to determine fair market value.
✅ Coordinate repairs and inspections to preserve property value.
✅ Manage sales to ensure transparency and compliance with probate court requirements.
✅ Document every step to avoid claims of mismanagement.

The Role of a CPRES in Resolving Probate Disputes

As a Certified Probate Real Estate Specialist, I bring a unique blend of real estate expertise and probate knowledge to the table. Here’s how I help families and attorneys navigate disputes:

🏠 Neutral Valuations: Providing accurate, unbiased property appraisals that all parties can trust.
📊 Market Analysis: Helping set realistic expectations for property sales or buyouts.
🤝 Facilitating Communication: Acting as a neutral advisor to reduce tension and foster cooperation.
💼 Transaction Management: Ensuring smooth, court-approved property sales that comply with probate rules.

Case Study: Resolving a Family Real Estate Dispute

The Situation: Three siblings inherited their parents’ home. Two wanted to sell; one wanted to keep it as a family gathering place.

The Conflict: The sibling who wanted to keep it couldn’t afford to buy out the others. Emotions ran high, and litigation loomed.

The Resolution: I provided a neutral property appraisal and outlined options:
✅ Sale and division of proceeds
✅ Buyout with financing assistance
✅ Co-ownership agreement with clear terms

After a facilitated family meeting, the siblings agreed to sell, split the proceeds, and use some of the funds to create a memorial scholarship in their parents’ name—preserving family harmony and legacy.

Conclusion

Probate disputes are challenging, but they don’t have to destroy families or deplete estates. By understanding the common causes and resolution options—and by working with experienced professionals like a CPRES—you can navigate these challenges with confidence and care.

If you’re facing a probate dispute or want to protect your family from future conflicts, I’m here to help.

💬 Questions about probate disputes? Drop them below—I’d be honored to help!
👍 Like and share this post to support others navigating estate challenges.
🔔 Subscribe for more insights on probate real estate and estate planning.